Would the examiners have noticed that information was missing?

Question

Anne Denniston said:

I recently edited 178 items in a reference list.  There was a lot of missing information because (a) he had believed that the citations journal publishers supplied gave him all the required information and had not looked further for page/article numbers; and (b) he never gave the editors of books.

I created a separate list of 64 comments and made the revisions listed below. (The formatting changes were mostly because spaces imported from the internet were, for some reason, in a different font from the default font and it affected the line spacing so I had to change it. The moves were mostly putting the retrieved date in the correct place.)

The work took 12 hours 40 minutes, i.e., an average of 4,27 minutes per item.

Would the examiners have noticed that information was missing if I hadn’t edited the reference list? I suppose I am really asking, ‘Was the work worth my time and my client’s money?’

Answer 1

Christien Terblanche said:
Yes!!! The referencing is a separate item on the report examiners use to evaluate the study. There are different things they look for. Many students think the reference list is a negligible thing at the end, but it is really important and the examiners consider the level of detail and correctness. They are also quick to pick up errors because they are in the field and often know many of the sources well themselves.

Answer 2

Jacqui Baumgardt said:
Yes, I think the examiners would. I have had students send me their examiners’ comments when they do their corrections and this comes up quite often.

Be that as it may, I only edit the formatting – and tell the student to complete the missing info as I don’t believe that is my responsibility. I may coach them a bit in my comments as to how to do this or I may refer them to their librarian.

Answer 3

Another PEG member said:
Yes, I think they would have noticed, at least at the doctoral level.

During my studies at different universities, I had to keep swapping between academic styles, e.g., Harvard, Chicago, APA7, AGPS (Australian Govt.), and while—at the postgraduate level—some examiners let a few minor errors pass, others deducted marks for missing periods or commas used instead of periods. When you are accustomed to a particular style—in my case, APA7—switching to another requires significantly more focus because the punctuation rules differ.

My master’s thesis listed more than 200 references, and reviewing it now, I can see a few places where I used a comma instead of a period, none of which were commented on. My current doctoral thesis is likely to have closer to 500 references, and I have been advised to ensure the reference list is error-free in case I have a very pedantic examiner.

I recently received the proofs of a journal article that is about to be published, and while the body of the article needed only a few minor edits, the reference list required significant corrections because the publisher used its own hybrid style, and I had missed one specific difference. I had just finished a day’s work searching for all the missing publisher locations (and, in some cases, having to open a book in Google Books to see which location a book referenced on its imprint page as the publisher listed several locations) when you shared your wonderful link to the Publisher Address List.

Proofreading reference lists is tedious and demanding; I’m not surprised it took you almost 13 hours. I do agree with the previous comment, though. If publisher locations, page numbers or DOIs are missing, I would push that work back on the student and just correct the punctuation and formatting.

Answer 4

Elly Grossman said:
In days gone by when I was examining theses, the reference list was my entry point to the task. I would quickly scan the text and cross check the in-text citations with those in the reference list. Thus in one fell swoop the references were checked while getting an initial acquaintance with the work.

Thereafter the hard work of examination started.

In answer to your question, I would have noticed mistakes in the reference list, as it would be my first task and I was mentally fresh.

If it were the last item to tackle, I would have been weary and perhaps not noticed small errors.

Answer 5

Pat Mayers said:
I agree with Elly. I still supervise and examine PhD and masters theses. The reference list is often where I start – it helps to get a sense of the thesis – the range of sources, how current these are (if applicable), and attention to detail. So I would definitely have noticed and commented in my report.

An an examiner, I am not too concerned about the minor errors. These would not influence my mark allocation.

As a supervisor – I go through the references, highlight all that are incorrect and return to the student to correct.

As an editor – it’s also often where I start!

Conclusion

Anne Denniston said:

Thank you for your thoughtful and encouraging replies. I will take even more pleasure in my reference checks now that I know they are important to the examiners as well as me.

I don’t provide the missing information for the students (because that is unethical for examinable texts) but I do make sure the information is there before I tell it them to look for it (and add tips in the comments).


PEG members can view this discussion on the PEGforum Google Group. The thread, Would the examiners have noticed?, started on Wed, 28 Oct 2026 at 20:17.

Published 31 October 2026

946 words